FpML Issues Tracker
closed
Minor
Always
Validation Rules
Admin
None
Summary
ird-28 could be written more clearly and consistently with the other rules.
The rule today is: " Context: MandatoryEarlyTermination (complex type) ird-28 (Mandatory) In cashSettlement/cashSettlementValuationDate/dateRelativeTo, the @href attribute must point to the @id attribute of mandatoryEarlyTerminationDate. "
To be consistent with the other rules, the form should be: " Context: MandatoryEarlyTermination (complex type) ird-28 (Mandatory) cashSettlement/cashSettlementValuationDate/dateRelativeTo/@href equals mandatoryEarlyTerminationDate/@id. "
NB The consistent form of the rule is much clearer.
Notes:
matthewdr
05/14/08 3:25 pm
Also, ird-28 should move from IRD Rules to ID/IDREF Rules.
iyermakova
05/24/08 2:28 am
– As per Val WG agreement, the rules ird-28 was corrected as proposed above, Added condition for optional ” cashSettlement/cashSettlementValuationDate” element
The change was committed to trunk and branchesFpML-5-0
“Context: MandatoryEarlyTermination (complex type)
ird-28 (Mandatory)
If cashSettlement/cashSettlementValuationDate exists, cashSettlement/cashSettlementValuationDate/dateRelativeTo/@href attribute must point to the mandatoryEarlyTerminationDate/@id attribute.”
– The proposal to move rule ird-28 from IRD Rules to ID/IDREF Rules needs to be reviewed at Val WG
matthewdr
06/03/08 1:55 pm
Agreed at VWG last time and this time to move this to the IDREF rules and write it in the new style. Marc Gratacos to implement.
lyteck
06/03/08 6:44 pm
deprecated ird-28, replaced by new ref-38
used the following format, instead of that suggested in note 1510. This is to be consistent with all the other Ref rules: