FpML Issues Tracker

718: Valid test case valid-cd-34-01.xml is invalid (cf. rule cd-25)

May 28, 2008

closed

Minor

Always

Validation Rules

MarkAddison

None

Summary

Valid test case valid-cd-34-01.xml is invalid (cf. rule cd-25)

rule cd-25: If physicalSettlementTerms exists them it must contain settlementCurrency, physicalSettlementPeriod, escrow and deliverableObligations/accruedInterest

In this case, the document does not contain //physicalSettlementTerms/deliverableObligations/accruedInterest

Resolution, either the rule is incorrect and needs to be redefined or the document needs to be amended to conform to the rule (i.e. by adding an appropriate accruedInterest element)

Notes:

  • matthewdr

    06/03/08 1:40 pm

    Agreed at VWG. Marc Gratacos to implement a fix to the example.

    Potentially a collision between cd-25 and cd-34 that Marc Gratacos will look into.

  • lyteck

    12/11/08 7:38 pm

    valid-cd-34-01.xml indeed contains:
    – 3 out of 4 elements required in cd-25
    – category = ReferenceObligationsOnly, required in cd-34

    USD
    ReferenceObligationsOnly

    true

    According to the schema annotations and other examples (e.g., valid-cd-25-01.xml), the two parameters aren’t directly related and can coexist. We could have:


    true
    ReferenceObligationsOnly

    will fix valid-cd-34-01.xml, wrt rule cd-25, by adding element

  • Leave an update

    You must be logged in to post an update.